Appellant / Complainant
Vijay Kumar Mishra
Respondent
Mentor Infrastructure Private Limited
mentor infrastructure private limited
₹47,504
Both (Settled)
Case Procedural History & Progression Tree
Visual step-by-step tree detailing dispute origin, interim hearings, and final tribunal ruling.
Complaint Filing & Dispute Registration
Complaint registered under Case ID 0901126011612021 by Vijay Kumar Mishra against Mentor Infrastructure Private Limited before up_rera.
Hearing
The appeal was disposed of as withdrawn following a settlement where the respondent refunded an inadvertently deducted tax amount to the appellant via cheque.
Delay condonation
The matter is adjourned to 21.03.2025 following a request by the respondent's counsel and confirmation that costs were paid to the appellant.
Delay condonation
At the request of the respondent's counsel, the tribunal has adjourned the appeal for orders/hearing to 17.03.2025.
Delay condonation
The respondent has agreed to refund the amount of taxes deducted from the appellant's deposit and was granted time to handover cheques for said amount by the next hearing date.
Delay condonation
The Tribunal refers to a previous order passed in Appeal No. 139/2021 for the orders regarding this matter.
Delay condonation
The Tribunal granted a last opportunity to the respondent to pay costs imposed on 19.12.2024 and to comply with the order dated 23.11.2024 regarding the filing of a head-wise tax calculation chart.
Delay condonation
The Tribunal granted an adjournment requested by the respondent's counsel, subject to a cost of Rs. 500/- to be paid to the appellant, and rescheduled the matter for 22.01.2025.
Hearing
The Tribunal granted the respondent additional time to file a head-wise tax calculation chart and scheduled the matter for orders on 19.12.2024.
Hearing
The Tribunal directed the respondent to provide a head-wise explanation of taxes demanded and a detailed calculation chart for service tax and GST within seven days.
Hearing
The Tribunal granted an adjournment following a request from the appellant's counsel and scheduled the appeal for final hearing on 27.09.2024.
Hearing
The Tribunal granted the appellant one week to file a reply to the newly uploaded C.A. Certificate and scheduled the matter for hearing on 28.08.2024.
Hearing
The Tribunal directed the respondent to provide a written breakdown of tax deductions made from the refund amount, allowing the appellant one week to file a reply once that information is provided.
Hearing
The Tribunal granted an adjournment request from the appellant's counsel due to unavailability and illness, rescheduling the hearing for 19.07.2024.
Hearing
The Tribunal listed a defective appeal for hearing on 24.05.2024 regarding the application for condonation of delay and directed parties to exchange pleadings.
Hearing
The Tribunal directed the appellant to file an objection/response regarding discrepancies in the respondent's calculations of interest and deductions within one week. The matter is scheduled for hearing on 25.04.2024.
Hearing
The Tribunal has issued a routine procedural order to list the appeal for hearing on 22.03.2024.
Hearing
The Tribunal refers the parties to a previously passed order in Appeal No. 139/2021 for further directions.
Hearing
The Tribunal granted an exemption for the CMD's appearance due to health grounds and accepted her unconditional apology after compliance with previous directions. The appellant is permitted 10 days to file a response or objection to the provided calculation details.
Hearing
The Tribunal imposed a penalty of Rs. 5,000/- on the CMD of the respondent for non-appearance and directed him to appear personally on 07.08.2023 to show cause regarding non-compliance with previous orders.
Hearing
The Tribunal permitted counsel for the respondent to withdraw due to lack of instructions and summoned the CMD of M/S. Mentor Infrastructure Private Limited to show cause why proceedings should not be initiated for non-compliance with previous orders.
For Order
The Respondent is directed to comply with previous orders by providing necessary information to the applicant within 10 days and filing an affidavit confirming these details within 15 days.
For Order
The Tribunal granted the respondent a final one-week extension to provide interest details and tax deduction explanations, warning that failure to comply will result in summoning the CMD and potential proceedings under Section 64 of the Act.
Hearing
The Tribunal directed the respondent to file an affidavit within 10 days providing details of interest calculations, tax deductions, and explanations regarding unpaid interest during the Covid-19 period.
Hearing
The Tribunal granted an adjournment at the request of the appellant, who intends to apply for new legal counsel, and rescheduled the matter for 15.03.2023.
Hearing
The Tribunal directed the Respondent to pay the outstanding tax amount of Rs. 78,231/- to the Appellant, provided it falls within the agreed terms, before the next hearing date.
Hearing
The court granted a request by the respondent's counsel to adjourn the matter, rescheduling the case for further orders on 03.11.2022.
Hearing
The Tribunal directed the Respondent to clarify and submit details regarding the grounds for deductions made from the refund amount paid to the Appellant. The matter is listed for 17.10.2022, requiring the Respondent's authorized representative to appear and explain the basis of said deductions.
Hearing
The Tribunal granted an adjournment request by the appellant's counsel and noted that a settlement between the parties is likely being pursued outside of the Tribunal.
Hearing
The Tribunal directed the respondent to refund Rs. 3,00,000/- to the appellant with interest at MCLR+1% and noted that the respondent shall make no further claims against the appellant.
Hearing
The Tribunal granted an adjournment at the request of the respondent due to the absence of their authorized representative and scheduled the matter for hearing on 27.05.2022, directing both parties to appear in person.
Hearing
The Tribunal directed the applicant to appear in person and ordered the respondent company to appear with an authorized representative empowered to make decisions at the next hearing on 25.05.2022.
Hearing
The Tribunal allowed an adjournment application filed by the respondent's counsel and rescheduled the appeal for hearing on 20.04.2022.
Hearing
The Tribunal directed the parties to submit the project brochure and allotment letters within one week and scheduled the appeal for hearing on 19.01.2022.
Hearing
The Tribunal noted that pleadings have been exchanged and scheduled the appeal for a hearing on January 3, 2022.
Hearing
The Tribunal granted a request for adjournment due to the illness of the respondent's senior counsel and rescheduled the matter for final hearing on 22.12.2021.
Hearing
The Tribunal granted a request for adjournment by the respondent's counsel and scheduled the appeal for hearing on 07.12.2021.
Hearing
The Tribunal granted the appellant 10 days to file a reply to the respondent's objections and scheduled the final hearing for November 16, 2021.
Delay condonation
The Tribunal adjourned the appeal due to the respondent's counsel's inability to attend and directed both parties to exchange objections and replies via email within specified timelines.
For Order
The Tribunal directed the appellant to serve the respondent via dasti summons due to non-appearance of the respondent and scheduled the next hearing for 07.04.2021.
Defect Removal
The Tribunal issued notice to the respondent regarding an application for condonation of delay and directed the parties to exchange objections and replies via email and the e-portal before the next hearing on 10.03.2021.
Tribunal Order #0901126011612021-24-02-2025
The respondent has agreed to refund the amount of taxes deducted from the appellant's deposit and was granted time to handover cheques for said amount by the next hearing date.
Tribunal Order #0901126011612021-27-09-2024
The Tribunal directed the respondent to provide a head-wise explanation of taxes demanded and a detailed calculation chart for service tax and GST within seven days.
Tribunal Order #0901126011612021-22-03-2024
The Tribunal directed the appellant to file an objection/response regarding discrepancies in the respondent's calculations of interest and deductions within one week. The matter is scheduled for hearing on 25.04.2024.
Tribunal Order #0901126011612021-03-08-2023
The Tribunal imposed a penalty of Rs. 5,000/- on the CMD of the respondent for non-appearance and directed him to appear personally on 07.08.2023 to show cause regarding non-compliance with previous orders.
Tribunal Order #0901126011612021-24-04-2023
The Tribunal granted the respondent a final one-week extension to provide interest details and tax deduction explanations, warning that failure to comply will result in summoning the CMD and potential proceedings under Section 64 of the Act.
Tribunal Order #0901126011612021-22-12-2022
The Tribunal directed the Respondent to pay the outstanding tax amount of Rs. 78,231/- to the Appellant, provided it falls within the agreed terms, before the next hearing date.
Tribunal Order #0901126011612021-27-09-2022
The Tribunal directed the Respondent to clarify and submit details regarding the grounds for deductions made from the refund amount paid to the Appellant. The matter is listed for 17.10.2022, requiring the Respondent's authorized representative to appear and explain the basis of said deductions.
Tribunal Order #0901126011612021-21-03-2025
The appeal was disposed of as withdrawn following a settlement where the respondent refunded an inadvertently deducted tax amount to the appellant via cheque.
Tribunal Order #0901126011612021-22-01-2025
The Tribunal granted a last opportunity to the respondent to pay costs imposed on 19.12.2024 and to comply with the order dated 23.11.2024 regarding the filing of a head-wise tax calculation chart.
Tribunal Order #0901126011612021-19-12-2024
The Tribunal granted an adjournment requested by the respondent's counsel, subject to a cost of Rs. 500/- to be paid to the appellant, and rescheduled the matter for 22.01.2025.
Tribunal Order #0901126011612021-19-07-2024
The Tribunal directed the respondent to provide a written breakdown of tax deductions made from the refund amount, allowing the appellant one week to file a reply once that information is provided.
Tribunal Order #0901126011612021-22-09-2023
The Tribunal granted an exemption for the CMD's appearance due to health grounds and accepted her unconditional apology after compliance with previous directions. The appellant is permitted 10 days to file a response or objection to the provided calculation details.
Tribunal Order #0901126011612021-05-07-2023
The Tribunal permitted counsel for the respondent to withdraw due to lack of instructions and summoned the CMD of M/S. Mentor Infrastructure Private Limited to show cause why proceedings should not be initiated for non-compliance with previous orders.
Tribunal Order #0901126011612021-22-05-2023
The Respondent is directed to comply with previous orders by providing necessary information to the applicant within 10 days and filing an affidavit confirming these details within 15 days.
Tribunal Order #0901126011612021-15-03-2023
The Tribunal directed the respondent to file an affidavit within 10 days providing details of interest calculations, tax deductions, and explanations regarding unpaid interest during the Covid-19 period.
Tribunal Order #0901126011612021-27-05-2022
The Tribunal directed the respondent to refund Rs. 3,00,000/- to the appellant with interest at MCLR+1% and noted that the respondent shall make no further claims against the appellant.
Tribunal Disposal & Final Award Ruling
The appeal was disposed of as withdrawn following a settlement where the respondent refunded an inadvertently deducted tax amount to the appellant via cheque. Awarded in favor of Both (Settled).
Final Tribunal Order & Ruling Verdict Summary
Official Ruling Summary
The appeal was disposed of as withdrawn following a settlement where the respondent refunded an inadvertently deducted tax amount to the appellant via cheque.
Ruling Awarded To
Both (Settled)
Appearing Legal Counsel & Advocates
Appellant Advocate(s)
- Vaibhav Tiwari
- Akshay Bajpai
Respondent Advocate(s)
- Saurabh Misra
- Krishna Kumar Singh
Official RERA Tribunal Orders (16)
The respondent has agreed to refund the amount of taxes deducted from the appellant's deposit and was granted time to handover cheques for said amount by the next hearing date.
The Tribunal directed the respondent to provide a head-wise explanation of taxes demanded and a detailed calculation chart for service tax and GST within seven days.
The Tribunal directed the appellant to file an objection/response regarding discrepancies in the respondent's calculations of interest and deductions within one week. The matter is scheduled for hearing on 25.04.2024.
The Tribunal imposed a penalty of Rs. 5,000/- on the CMD of the respondent for non-appearance and directed him to appear personally on 07.08.2023 to show cause regarding non-compliance with previous orders.
The Tribunal granted the respondent a final one-week extension to provide interest details and tax deduction explanations, warning that failure to comply will result in summoning the CMD and potential proceedings under Section 64 of the Act.
The Tribunal directed the Respondent to pay the outstanding tax amount of Rs. 78,231/- to the Appellant, provided it falls within the agreed terms, before the next hearing date.
The Tribunal directed the Respondent to clarify and submit details regarding the grounds for deductions made from the refund amount paid to the Appellant. The matter is listed for 17.10.2022, requiring the Respondent's authorized representative to appear and explain the basis of said deductions.
The appeal was disposed of as withdrawn following a settlement where the respondent refunded an inadvertently deducted tax amount to the appellant via cheque.
The Tribunal granted a last opportunity to the respondent to pay costs imposed on 19.12.2024 and to comply with the order dated 23.11.2024 regarding the filing of a head-wise tax calculation chart.
The Tribunal granted an adjournment requested by the respondent's counsel, subject to a cost of Rs. 500/- to be paid to the appellant, and rescheduled the matter for 22.01.2025.
The Tribunal directed the respondent to provide a written breakdown of tax deductions made from the refund amount, allowing the appellant one week to file a reply once that information is provided.
The Tribunal granted an exemption for the CMD's appearance due to health grounds and accepted her unconditional apology after compliance with previous directions. The appellant is permitted 10 days to file a response or objection to the provided calculation details.
The Tribunal permitted counsel for the respondent to withdraw due to lack of instructions and summoned the CMD of M/S. Mentor Infrastructure Private Limited to show cause why proceedings should not be initiated for non-compliance with previous orders.
The Respondent is directed to comply with previous orders by providing necessary information to the applicant within 10 days and filing an affidavit confirming these details within 15 days.
The Tribunal directed the respondent to file an affidavit within 10 days providing details of interest calculations, tax deductions, and explanations regarding unpaid interest during the Covid-19 period.
The Tribunal directed the respondent to refund Rs. 3,00,000/- to the appellant with interest at MCLR+1% and noted that the respondent shall make no further claims against the appellant.
Need to research all rulings for mentor infrastructure private limited?
Extract builder dossiers, check execution status, and draft RERA appeal petitions in minutes using TathyaGrid.